Determine Whether or not to Ban Laptops within the Classroom (Opinion)


I’ve heard that it’s higher for college kids to take notes by hand. Ought to I ban laptops within the classroom?

Blanket bans aren’t a good suggestion. Right here’s one thing I wrote not too long ago in regards to the matter for Character Lab as a Tip of the Week:

Hello, I’m Danny Oppenheimer. If laptops are banned in native school rooms, you’ll have heard of me. That’s as a result of it was my lab that confirmed that college students carry out higher after they take notes by hand than after they use laptops. Earlier than I knew it, these research had been used as justification for laptop computer bans in school rooms across the nation.

I obtain a whole lot of offended emails berating me about these insurance policies—which is unlucky, since I don’t really advocate blanket laptop computer bans and by no means have. In truth, I don’t even ban laptops in my very own courses.

Let me clarify. In my analysis, we confirmed college students TED Talks and had them take notes both on laptops or with a pen and paper. As a result of most individuals can kind quicker than they will write, college students utilizing laptops transcribed the talks almost verbatim. However college students who took handwritten notes couldn’t, in order that they took notes in their very own phrases. Writing by hand required college students to know, synthesize, and summarize the content material. Deeper processing of the knowledge, in flip, led to improved studying. Because of this, college students within the longhand situation scored increased on assessments.

Academics across the nation began banning laptops of their courses. However what really interfered with studying was senseless transcription of a lecture. Laptops merely enabled that by permitting college students to take notes extra rapidly.

Like most know-how, laptops aren’t universally useful or dangerous within the classroom; they’re useful or dangerous for particular functions. The worth of a laptop computer within the classroom will depend on the purpose of a lesson plan, the character of the fabric, kind of scholars being taught, and extra.

As an illustration, a lesson on learn how to discover and consider data on the web may be higher when college students have entry to laptops. A lesson on algebraic expressions, however, won’t be. College students with sure disabilities might have a laptop computer; different college students may be unable to make use of one. If a lesson requires actual quotes, then laptops are very best. But when the purpose is conceptual understanding, laptops can create temptations for verbatim transcription, which is counterproductive.

Don’t ignore context when deciding whether or not or to not enable laptops in your class. The reply to the query, “Are laptops good or unhealthy for studying?” is: It relies upon.

Do encourage college students to take notes in their very own phrases. Take into consideration the purpose of a lesson and whether or not or not the presence of laptops will assist or hinder it. Simply as there’s no one-size-fits-all mode to studying, the identical goes for decrees about know-how.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.