Sorry To Say That $10K Per Day Penalty For Donald Trump’s Contempt Received’t Lower It


donald trump

(Picture by Drew Angerer/Getty Photos)

“Contempt” is a scary-sounding phrase. Its literal which means is one thing near “disdain” or “scorn.”

Contempt may be scary in its authorized iteration too. Whereas the specifics differ by jurisdiction, in fact, the implications of defying a courtroom’s directions can theoretically be dire, as much as and together with having to sit down in jail till you determine possibly it’s really price listening to what the decide has to say.

There are numerous high-profile historic examples of draconian contempt sanctions. For instance, journalists have been jailed for contempt associated to refusals to disclose their sources — for months, in some instances.

But, within the day-to-day operations of the justice system, actual penalties for contempt are fairly uncommon. Excluding high-profile instances reported within the media, in just a little over 10 years of apply, I’ve by no means even heard of anyone really being jailed for contempt. I’ve seen a couple of folks pay cash on the final minute to keep at bay threatened contempt. One time, I noticed a decide refuse to carry events in contempt on the idea that since they disobeyed his earlier orders there was no purpose to suspect that holding them in contempt would guarantee future compliance.

Contempt sounds scary, and in distinctive circumstances it’s honest-to-God scary. However more often than not it’s toothless. Judges don’t wish to get blended up within the inevitable authorized knots contempt proceedings trigger, and courts don’t have a military to really implement their orders if they’ll impose any penalties in need of fast incarceration (by which case, I suppose, the bailiff can simply seize the offending social gathering within the courtroom).

Lately, New York Legal professional Common Letitia James filed paperwork in search of to carry Donald Trump in contempt of courtroom. In the midst of New York’s investigation into Trump’s enterprise practices, James has subpoenaed him so as to get hold of paperwork and data, and a earlier courtroom order required compliance with the newest subpoena by March 31.

In line with James’s workplace, Trump failed to totally adjust to the subpoena. The truth is, the lawyer normal’s movement paperwork point out that Trump “didn’t comply in any respect” — his attorneys allegedly refused to supply “any” paperwork. James is asking that the courtroom impose a fantastic on Trump of not less than $10,000 per day till he complies with the subpoena. Trump’s attorneys are set to defend in opposition to James’s movement in courtroom on April 25.

As satisfying as it will be to listen to that Donald Trump was held in contempt, that is probably simply one other exemplar of the impotence of contempt proceedings. For one factor, even when he was held in contempt and penalized with a $10,000 a day fantastic, the man is supposedly price one thing within the neighborhood of $2.5 billion (that’s the conservative estimate; he’s beforehand lied about being price 4 occasions as a lot, which is sort of what received him in hassle with the New York lawyer normal within the first place).

It’s troublesome to think about simply how a lot cash a billion {dollars} actually is. Donald Trump is 75 years previous. Let’s say he lives one other 10 years, to the ripe previous age of 85. If he’s fined $10,000 per day, that will be $3.65 million per 12 months, or just a little over $36.5 million over the subsequent 10 years (there could be a pair leap years in there too). That’s lower than 1.5% of his present fortune of $2.5 billion. So, Trump might comfortably pay a $10,000 per day fantastic every single day for the remainder of his life, and it wouldn’t quantity to rather more than a rounding error for him.

Plus, somebody must attempt to gather the cash. What occurs when Trump merely refuses to pay the fines? The man doesn’t have a stellar document of assembly his obligations.

I’m positive the NYAG’s coronary heart is in the precise place, and the attorneys working this case should function inside the inherent structural limitations of a contempt continuing. Nonetheless, I want they might/would take an individual’s web price under consideration when deciding what to ask for as a sanction. Ten grand per day shouldn’t be a significant risk to Trump. I assure he’s already paying his attorneys greater than $10,000 per day anyway.

That is one more missed alternative to carry Donald Trump accountable, to point out the entire nation that the foundations apply to everybody, even the wealthy, even former presidents. Sadly, no one appears to have the spine for that.

Jonathan Wolf is a civil litigator and writer of Your Debt-Free JD (affiliate hyperlink). He has taught authorized writing, written for all kinds of publications, and made it each his enterprise and his pleasure to be financially and scientifically literate. Any views he expresses are most likely pure gold, however are nonetheless solely his personal and shouldn’t be attributed to any group with which he’s affiliated. He wouldn’t wish to share the credit score anyway. He may be reached at


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.